Two Silver Coin Sets, One Core Build
If you are looking to upgrade your game tokens with metal coins, Fantasy Coins offers two silver-themed sets: Fire Silver and Pirate Silver. Both are produced by Fantasy Coins LLC and share the same physical construction. The main difference is the theme stamped on each coin. This comparison focuses on what is confirmed by the product records so you can decide which set fits your table.
What the Catalog Confirms
- Fantasy Coins - Fire Silver: Set of ten Fire-themed metal coins by Fantasy Coins LLC. Heavy-weight, finely-minted coins crafted from zinc and nickel with high-relief 3D detailing and a hand-buffed silver finish. Dimensions: 30mm x 2.5mm. The Fire Silver coins match the same metal composition, weight class, and finish as the Pirate Silver set, so your handling experience will be identical.
Fantasy Coins - Fire Silver - Fantasy Coins - Pirate Silver: Set of ten Pirate-themed, officially licensed metal coins by Fantasy Coins LLC. Heavy-weight, finely-minted coins crafted from zinc and nickel with high-relief 3D detailing and a hand-buffed silver finish. Dimensions: 30mm x 2.5mm. Pirate Silver coins are officially licensed and share the same premium build. The theme is the only confirmed difference between the two sets.
Fantasy Coins - Pirate Silver
Fire Silver vs Pirate Silver: Key Differences
Both sets contain ten coins, each 30mm in diameter and 2.5mm thick. They are made from zinc and nickel with a hand-buffed silver finish. The only confirmed distinction is the theme: Fire Silver features fire-themed imagery, while Pirate Silver features pirate-themed designs and is officially licensed. The catalog does not confirm any difference in weight, packaging, or durability.
- Theme: Fire Silver: fire motifs. Pirate Silver: pirate motifs (officially licensed).
- Material & Finish: Both: zinc and nickel, high-relief 3D detailing, hand-buffed silver finish.
- Quantity & Size: Both: 10 coins, 30mm x 2.5mm.
- Price (catalog): Fire Silver: USD 5.98 (compare at USD 9.49). Pirate Silver: USD 6.26 (compare at USD 9.49).
Which Set Should You Choose?
Since the core specifications are identical, your decision comes down to theme. If your game involves elemental magic, dragons, or a fiery setting, Fire Silver is the natural pick. If you run a pirate campaign, a naval-themed game, or want officially licensed coinage, Pirate Silver is the better match. The slight price difference (USD 0.28) is negligible, so let the artwork guide you.
If you need a large number of coins, note that each set contains only ten pieces. For games that require many tokens, you may want to purchase multiple sets of the same theme or mix themes for variety. The catalog does not confirm whether the coins are sold in bulk packs.
