Two metal token sets, one question
When you're upgrading your tabletop currency, the choice often comes down to two similar-looking metal coin sets: the Fantasy Coins 5 Credits and the Orion Coins Generic 5 Value. Both are heavy, finely minted zinc and nickel tokens with a silver finish, but they differ in size, price, and visual character. Here's how to decide which set belongs on your game table.
Fantasy Coins 5 Credits vs Orion Coins Generic 5 Value
The core differences are size, finish, and price. Fantasy Coins are smaller and more affordable per set, while Orion Coins are larger with a more antique look.
- Size and weight feel: Fantasy Coins measure 20mm x 2.5mm, making them compact and stackable. Orion Coins are 25mm x 2mm, offering a wider, flatter token that feels more substantial in hand. If your game uses small token spaces, the 20mm size may fit better; if you want a more prominent coin, the 25mm Orion set is the way to go.
- Finish and theme: Fantasy Coins have a lightly aged silver finish with a sci-fi '5 Credit' design, ideal for futuristic or sci-fi campaigns. Orion Coins feature a hand-buffed antique silver finish with a generic '5' value, making them versatile for fantasy, steampunk, or any setting where you want a classic coin look without a specific theme.
- Price per set: Fantasy Coins are priced at $7.39 (compare at $9.99), while Orion Coins cost $5.75 (compare at $8.99). Both are budget-friendly, but Orion Coins offer a lower entry price per set, especially if you need multiple sets for larger games.
What the catalog confirms
- Fantasy Coins - 5 Credits: Set of ten themed metal coins by Fantasy Coins LLC. These heavy-weight, finely-minted coins are crafted from zinc and nickel with high-relief 3D detailing and a hand-buffed finish. Dimensions: 20mm x 2.5mm. Confirms the compact size and sci-fi theme, so you know these are designed for games where a smaller, themed token works best.
Fantasy Coins - 5 Credits - Orion Coins - Generic 5 Value: Set of ten generic 5 value metal coins. These heavy-weight, finely-minted coins are crafted from zinc and nickel with high-relief 3D detailing and a hand-buffed antique silver finish. Dimensions: 25mm x 2mm. Shows the larger, antique finish that gives these coins a more universal, old-world feel, suitable for a wider range of campaign settings.
Orion Coins - Generic 5 Value
Which set fits your game?
If your game board has small circular spaces for currency tokens, the 20mm Fantasy Coins are the safer fit. They also suit sci-fi themes where 'credits' are the standard currency. If you prefer a larger coin that feels more like a traditional doubloon or gold piece, and you want a generic value that works in any setting, the 25mm Orion Coins are the better choice.
Both sets come as ten coins, so for games that require more than ten tokens, you'll need to buy multiple sets. Consider the price difference: Orion Coins are cheaper per set, which can add up if you're buying several. However, the Fantasy Coins' themed design may be worth the extra cost for a sci-fi campaign.
The verdict
There's no universal winner—it depends on your game's size requirements and theme. For a sci-fi campaign with tight token spaces, Fantasy Coins 5 Credits are the practical pick. For a versatile, larger coin that works in any fantasy or historical setting, Orion Coins Generic 5 Value offer great value. Either way, you're upgrading from cardboard to metal that feels satisfying to handle.
